PJFP.com

Pursuit of Joy, Fulfillment, and Purpose

  • Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger on Index Funds

    In the world of investing, few names command as much respect as Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger. Their investment philosophy has been a guiding light for many, offering a blend of wisdom, simplicity, and practicality. Central to their approach is the endorsement of index funds, which they regard as a prudent choice for most individual investors. Let’s delve into their perspectives:

    Simplicity and Effectiveness

    Warren Buffett, known for his straightforward approach to investing, has long been an advocate of the simplicity and effectiveness of index funds. His recommendation for most individual investors, especially those who are not investment professionals, is to opt for a low-cost S&P 500 index fund. Buffett’s rationale is rooted in the difficulty of consistently outperforming the market. For the average investor, attempting to beat the market is often a futile endeavor fraught with unnecessary risks and costs.

    Cost Efficiency

    Both Buffett and Munger have been vocal critics of the hefty fees charged by many actively managed funds. They argue that these fees significantly diminish returns, contributing to the often lackluster performance of active funds compared to their benchmarks. In contrast, index funds are known for their low-cost structure, making them a more efficient choice for investors.

    Long-Term Investing

    The investment strategy espoused by Buffett and Munger emphasizes long-term thinking. This philosophy aligns perfectly with the nature of index funds, which are designed to mirror the performance of the broader market over extended periods. Such funds are less susceptible to the short-term volatility that can affect individual stocks, making them suitable for long-term investment strategies.

    Diversification

    A cornerstone of risk management in investing is diversification, and index funds excel in this area. By investing in a broad market index fund, one gains exposure to a diverse array of sectors and companies. This diversification minimizes the risks associated with single-stock investments and offers a more balanced portfolio.

    Passive Management

    Finally, the Buffett-Munger investment ethos criticizes excessive trading and speculation, favoring instead a passive, buy-and-hold approach. Index funds embody this philosophy, as they involve purchasing and holding a diversified portfolio that reflects the market index.

    Wrap Up

    In essence, the advocacy of Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger for index funds is a natural extension of their broader investment philosophy. They champion index funds for their simplicity, cost-efficiency, long-term growth potential, diversification benefits, and passive management style. For the average investor seeking a sensible, low-cost route to market returns, Buffett.

  • Deciphering THORChain

    THORChain is a decentralized liquidity protocol that stands out for enabling the exchange of assets across different blockchains in a permissionless and non-custodial manner. It’s built on the Cosmos SDK and operates as an independent Layer 1 cross-chain decentralized exchange (DEX). The protocol employs a liquidity pool model, similar to other protocols like Uniswap or Bancor, and is powered by its native liquidity token, RUNE. This token plays a crucial role in the network’s security and functionality, as it deterministically accrues value with more assets deposited into the network.

    One of the innovative aspects of THORChain is the Bifröst Protocol, which facilitates the connection between different blockchains. Nodes in the network run a Bifröst service that allows them to recognize and process inbound transactions from various blockchains, converting them into THORChain transactions. This allows for native asset settlement between multiple blockchains like Bitcoin, Ethereum, and others without the need for wrapping or pegging assets, thereby preserving the decentralized nature of the asset exchange.

    THORChain’s architecture also includes advanced cryptographic techniques like Threshold Signature Schemes (TSS) and Byzantine Fault Tolerance, which help secure the network. It functions as a proof-of-stake blockchain, allowing users to swap native assets across Layer 1 blockchains without losing custody of their assets to a central authority, which is a common concern with traditional centralized exchanges.

    Relating this to the image you’ve provided, which humorously demands to know where the yield comes from in an assertive manner, it touches on a crucial aspect of decentralized finance (DeFi) platforms like THORChain: the source of yield or returns for investors. In the case of THORChain, the yield primarily comes from trading fees and liquidity incentives. Users who provide liquidity to the pools receive a portion of the trading fees as well as additional incentives in the form of RUNE tokens, which can appreciate in value as the network grows and more assets are deposited.

  • Amazon Revolutionizes the Workplace with ‘Q’: The AI-Powered Assistant Transforming Business Efficiency

    Amazon Revolutionizes the Workplace with 'Q': The AI-Powered Assistant Transforming Business Efficiency

    https://aws.amazon.com/q/

    Amazon has unveiled ‘Q’, a generative AI-powered assistant tailored for business environments, marking a significant expansion in its AI capabilities. Designed to integrate seamlessly into workplaces, Amazon Q stands out with its ability to adapt to specific business needs, engaging in conversations, solving problems, generating content, and taking actions based on a company’s unique data and systems.

    Q’s primary focus is to enhance workplace efficiency by providing quick, relevant, and actionable information. It assists in streamlining tasks, accelerating decision-making, and fostering creativity and innovation. Its integration with Amazon Web Services (AWS) means that it brings 17 years of AWS expertise to the table, transforming how applications and workloads are built, deployed, and operated on AWS.

    Security and privacy are at the forefront of Amazon Q’s design. It respects existing governance identities, roles, and permissions within a business, ensuring a user without pre-authorization cannot access certain data via Q. This makes it compliant with stringent enterprise requirements from the outset.

    Q’s versatility is further highlighted in its application across various Amazon services. It facilitates the generation of visuals and dashboards in Amazon QuickSight, enhances customer service in Amazon Connect by providing real-time generative responses and suggestions, and will soon be integrated into AWS Supply Chain to aid in supply-and-demand planning.

    Amazon Q offers flexible pricing plans, starting at $20 per user per month for the Business plan, which covers general business expertise and QuickSight functionalities. For $25 per user per month, the Builder plan extends this coverage to include AWS-specific expertise for technical developers and IT professionals.

    This latest development is a strategic move by Amazon to solidify its position in the AI-driven corporate solutions market, competing against established players with a product that promises enhanced workplace productivity through customizability, security, and a wide range of applications.

    Clickable Headline:

    “Amazon Revolutionizes the Workplace with ‘Q’: The AI-Powered Assistant Transforming Business Efficiency”

    Features of Amazon Q Explained:

    1. Tailored Business Integration: Amazon Q can be customized to align with a company’s specific data and systems. This includes over 40 built-in connectors that enable it to access and utilize a wide range of corporate information and resources.
    2. Enhanced Workplace Productivity: Q specializes in streamlining tasks, speeding up decision-making processes, and encouraging innovation. It can summarize long documents, draft emails, conduct research, and even perform comparative analysis, thereby reducing time spent on repetitive tasks.
    3. AWS Expertise: With its foundation in AWS’s 17 years of experience, Amazon Q provides specialized support in building, deploying, and operating applications on AWS. This feature is particularly beneficial for developers and IT professionals.
    4. Security and Privacy: Designed with enterprise security needs in mind, Q adheres to existing governance frameworks and permissions within a company. It ensures that users can only access the information they are authorized to view, maintaining strict data security and privacy standards.
    5. Integration with Amazon Services:
    • QuickSight: Q assists in generating visuals, dashboards, and data-driven stories, simplifying complex data interpretation and decision-making processes.
    • Amazon Connect: It enhances customer service by providing agents with real-time responses and action suggestions during customer interactions.
    • AWS Supply Chain: Q will soon offer functionalities to help manage supply-and-demand challenges, providing insights and recommended actions for inventory management.
    1. Flexible Pricing Plans: Amazon Q is available in different pricing tiers to cater to varied business needs:

    This combination of features positions Amazon Q as a comprehensive solution for businesses seeking to harness AI for enhanced productivity, decision-making, and innovative problem-solving.

  • Unveiling the Truth Behind Crypto Investments: Who Really Invests and Why?

    The following article is based on this paper:

    https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4631021

    Cryptocurrency has been a buzzword for a while, but who’s really diving into this digital gold rush? A recent study sheds light on the faces and factors behind crypto investments, debunking some myths and confirming some hunches.

    Who’s Investing? Contrary to popular belief, crypto investors aren’t just tech-savvy millennials. The study reveals a diverse group, spanning various income levels. However, it’s the high-income earners leading the charge, similar to trends in stock market investments.

    Why Crypto? The allure of cryptocurrencies isn’t just their novelty. Three key drivers emerged:

    • High Returns: The past success stories of cryptocurrencies have caught many an investor’s eye.
    • Income Changes: Interestingly, people tend to invest more in crypto following a positive change in their income.
    • Inflation Worries: With rising inflation concerns, many view crypto as a potential safe haven, a digital hedge against diminishing currency value.

    Crypto vs. Stocks: It turns out, crypto isn’t replacing stocks or bonds in investors’ portfolios. Instead, it’s becoming an additional playground. Most crypto investors still maintain traditional investments. But there’s a catch – crypto investments are more sensitive to market changes. While stocks may hold steady through ups and downs, crypto investments tend to ride the rollercoaster of market returns more closely.

    Geographical and Income Insights: From coast to coast, cryptocurrency investment is gaining ground across the U.S. And while all income levels are participating, the bulk of the investment is coming from the wealthier segment.

    The Early Birds vs. The Latecomers: There’s a distinct difference in behavior between early crypto adopters and those who jumped on the bandwagon later. Early birds have a unique approach, particularly during market highs, differing significantly from newer investors.

    Cryptocurrency may be the new kid on the investment block, but it’s playing by some old rules. Investors are approaching it with a mix of traditional wisdom and new-age enthusiasm. This study not only offers a clearer picture of who is investing in crypto and why but also how it’s reshaping the landscape of personal finance.

  • Decoding Your MidJourney Bot Stats: A Guide to Understanding Your Discord Info Section

    Locating Your MidJourney Bot Information on Discord For those new to MidJourney Bot on Discord or unsure where to find this information, accessing your account details is straightforward. Once you’re in the Discord server where the MidJourney Bot is active, simply type a command like /info in the chat. This command prompts the bot to display your current subscription status, mode usage, and other relevant statistics. It’s a quick and efficient way to get a snapshot of your usage and plan details, ensuring you stay informed about the resources and options available to you within the MidJourney Bot environment.

    Navigating the complexities of the MidJourney Bot on Discord can sometimes feel like a journey in itself, especially when it comes to understanding the information provided in your account’s Info section. This guide aims to demystify the details, helping users to interpret their usage, subscription, and resource allocation effectively.

    Understanding the Basics

    The MidJourney Bot in Discord is a powerful tool for image generation, offering users a unique blend of AI-powered creativity and customization. With different subscription tiers and modes, it’s crucial to understand how your plan works and how your usage is tracked.

    Subscription Details

    First, let’s break down the subscription information. If you see a line like “Subscription: Pro (Active yearly, renews next on [date])”, this indicates your current subscription level (Pro, in this case) and the renewal date. This is straightforward, letting you know the status and type of your plan.

    Visibility Mode

    Some users might notice a “Visibility Mode” mentioned. This could refer to how your activity is displayed to others in the Discord community. For example, “Stealth” mode might mean your actions are less visible to others.

    Fast vs. Relax Mode

    MidJourney offers two primary modes for processing image generation requests: Fast Mode and Relax Mode. Fast Mode is designed for immediate GPU access, prioritizing your requests for quicker results. Relax Mode, on the other hand, queues your requests, usually taking longer but not consuming your Fast GPU time.

    Monthly GPU Time Allocation

    One of the most crucial pieces of information is your GPU time allocation, especially for Fast Mode. With a Pro subscription, you typically get 30 hours of Fast GPU time per month. This is a monthly allocation, and it does not roll over to the next month. Your usage stats, such as “8.56/30.0 hours (28.52%)”, indicate how much of this monthly allocation you’ve used.

    Lifetime and Relaxed Usage

    Your Lifetime Usage and Relaxed Usage stats show your overall activity on the service. The Lifetime Usage tracks the total number of images generated and the hours spent, while Relaxed Usage specifically tracks the activity in Relax Mode.

    Queued and Running Jobs

    Finally, “Queued Jobs” and “Running Jobs” provide a snapshot of your current activity. Queued Jobs show how many tasks are waiting in line (either in Fast or Relax mode), and Running Jobs indicate ongoing tasks.

    Understanding these statistics is key to maximizing the benefits of your MidJourney subscription. It helps you plan your activities, manage your resource allocation, and make the most of the service’s capabilities. Whether you’re a seasoned user or new to the platform, keeping a close eye on your Info section ensures you’re always in control of your creative journey on Discord.

  • Microsoft Transitions from Bing Chat to Copilot: A Strategic Rebranding

    Microsoft Transitions from Bing Chat to Copilot: A Strategic Rebranding

    In a significant shift in its AI strategy, Microsoft has announced the rebranding of Bing Chat to Copilot. This move underscores the tech giant’s ambition to make a stronger imprint in the AI-assisted search market, a space currently dominated by ChatGPT.

    The Evolution from Bing Chat to Copilot

    Microsoft introduced Bing Chat earlier this year, integrating a ChatGPT-like interface within its Bing search engine. The initiative marked a pivotal moment in Microsoft’s AI journey, pitting it against Google in the search engine war. However, the landscape has evolved rapidly, with the rise of ChatGPT gaining unprecedented attention. Microsoft’s rebranding to Copilot comes in the wake of OpenAI’s announcement that ChatGPT boasts a weekly user base of 100 million.

    A Dual-Pronged Strategy: Copilot for Consumers and Businesses

    Colette Stallbaumer, General Manager of Microsoft 365, clarified that Bing Chat and Bing Chat Enterprise would now collectively be known as Copilot. This rebranding extends beyond a mere name change; it represents a strategic pivot towards offering tailored AI solutions for both consumers and businesses.

    The Standalone Experience of Copilot

    In a departure from its initial integration within Bing, Copilot is set to become a more autonomous experience. Users will no longer need to navigate through Bing to access its features. This shift highlights Microsoft’s intent to offer a distinct, streamlined AI interaction platform.

    Continued Integration with Microsoft’s Ecosystem

    Despite the rebranding, Bing continues to play a crucial role in powering the Copilot experience. The tech giant emphasizes that Bing remains integral to their overall search strategy. Moreover, Copilot will be accessible in Bing and Windows, with a dedicated domain at copilot.microsoft.com, parallel to ChatGPT’s model.

    Competitive Landscape and Market Dynamics

    The rebranding decision arrives amid a competitive AI market. Microsoft’s alignment with Copilot signifies its intention to directly compete with ChatGPT and other AI platforms. However, the company’s partnership with OpenAI, worth billions, adds a complex layer to this competitive landscape.

    The Future of AI-Powered Search and Assistance

    As AI continues to revolutionize search and digital assistance, Microsoft’s Copilot is poised to be a significant player. The company’s ability to adapt and evolve in this dynamic field will be crucial to its success in challenging the dominance of Google and other AI platforms.

  • AI Revolutionizes Weather Forecasting: Google’s GraphCast Surpasses Traditional Methods

    In a groundbreaking development for meteorology, an AI model named GraphCast, developed by Google DeepMind, has outperformed conventional weather forecasting methods, as reported by a study in the peer-reviewed journal Science. This marks a significant milestone in weather prediction, suggesting a future of increased accuracy and efficiency.

    AI’s Meteorological Mastery

    GraphCast, Google DeepMind’s AI meteorology model, has demonstrated superior performance over the leading conventional system of the European Centre for Medium-range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF). Excelling in 90 percent of 1,380 metrics, GraphCast has shown remarkable accuracy in predicting temperature, pressure, wind speed, direction, and humidity.

    Speed and Efficiency

    One of the most striking aspects of GraphCast is its speed. It can predict hundreds of weather variables over a 10-day period at a global scale, achieving this feat in under one minute. This rapid processing ability marks a significant advancement in AI’s role in meteorology, drastically reducing the time and energy required for weather forecasting.

    A Leap in Machine Learning

    GraphCast employs a sophisticated “graph neural network” machine-learning architecture, trained on over four decades of ECMWF’s historical weather data. It processes current and historical atmospheric data to generate forecasts, contrasting sharply with traditional methods that rely on supercomputers and complex atmospheric physics equations.

    The Cost-Efficiency Advantage

    GraphCast’s efficiency doesn’t just lie in its speed and accuracy. It’s also estimated to be about 1,000 times cheaper in terms of energy consumption compared to traditional weather forecasting methods. This cost-effectiveness, coupled with its advanced prediction capabilities, was exemplified in its successful forecast of Hurricane Lee’s landfall in Nova Scotia.

    Limitations and Future Directions

    Despite its advancements, GraphCast is not without limitations. It hasn’t outperformed conventional models in all scenarios and currently lacks the granularity offered by traditional methods. However, its potential as a complementary tool to existing weather prediction techniques is acknowledged by researchers.

    Looking ahead, there are plans for further development and integration of AI models into weather prediction systems by ECMWF and the UK Met Office, signaling a new era in meteorology where AI plays a crucial role.

    Google DeepMind’s GraphCast represents a paradigm shift in weather forecasting, offering a glimpse into a future where AI-driven models provide faster, more accurate, and cost-efficient predictions. While it’s not a complete replacement for traditional methods, its integration heralds a new age of innovation in meteorological science.

  • Rebuttal to “Silicon Valley’s Worldview is not Just an Ideology, It’s a Personality Disorder”

    A response to this:
    https://crookedtimber.org/2023/11/15/silicon-valleys-worldview-is-not-just-an-ideology-its-a-personality-disorder/

    Surveillance and Manipulation

    While concerns about surveillance and data manipulation are valid, it’s important to recognize the broader context. Many Silicon Valley companies have made significant efforts to improve data privacy and security. These measures are often driven by both consumer demand and regulatory requirements, illustrating a more complex picture than simply profit-driven surveillance.

    Disruption and Monopoly

    The focus on disruption has undoubtedly led to market dominance in some areas. However, this disruption has also often resulted in significant consumer benefits, like improved services, lower costs, and technological advancements that were previously unimaginable.

    Oligarchy and Autocracy

    Silicon Valley’s relationship with governments is more nuanced than the portrayal of a simple shift towards autocracy. Many tech leaders actively engage in philanthropy and social causes, leveraging their resources for global benefit, which contradicts the notion of a solely autocratic ambition.

    Inequality and Concentration of Capital

    While there is indeed a concentration of wealth in Silicon Valley, this wealth has also funded numerous startups and innovations that contribute to the economy. Additionally, many tech companies are actively working on diversity and inclusion initiatives to combat inequality.

    Negation of Human Rights

    It’s an oversimplification to claim that Silicon Valley negates human rights. Many tech companies are at the forefront of championing various social causes, including human rights. This commitment is often reflected in their corporate policies and social initiatives.

    Racism, Misogyny, and Eugenics

    Although issues of racism and misogyny exist in Silicon Valley, as they do in many industries, there is a growing awareness and active measures being taken to address these problems. The industry has seen a significant push towards greater diversity and inclusivity.

    Destruction of Human Agency

    The claim that Silicon Valley destroys human agency overlooks the numerous ways in which technology has empowered individuals, giving them tools for creativity, learning, and personal growth.

    Media Control and State Exploitation

    While there are instances of media manipulation and tax avoidance strategies, it’s not a universal practice in Silicon Valley. Many tech companies actively support journalistic endeavors and have a transparent approach to taxation and corporate responsibility.

    Blame and Denial of Responsibility

    The tech industry is increasingly acknowledging its role in societal issues and is taking steps to address them. This includes efforts in ethical AI, responsible data usage, and engaging in dialogues about technology’s impact on society.

    Narrow Definition of Intelligence

    Silicon Valley’s emphasis on engineering and mathematical skills doesn’t necessarily equate to a dismissal of other forms of intelligence. The tech industry has increasingly recognized the importance of diverse skill sets, including emotional intelligence, creativity, and interdisciplinary knowledge.

    Long-termism and AI Risks

    Focusing on long-term AI risks doesn’t inherently mean neglecting current societal issues. Many in Silicon Valley are actively engaged in addressing present challenges while also preparing for future technological impacts.

    While Silicon Valley is not without its flaws, the portrayal of its ideology as a personality disorder overlooks the complexities and positive contributions of the tech industry. A more balanced view recognizes both the challenges and the significant advancements Silicon Valley has brought to the modern world.

  • Revolutionizing Healthcare: Forward Launches AI-Powered CarePods to Transform Medical Services

    TL;DR: Forward has introduced the Forward CarePod, an innovative AI doctor’s office, designed to revolutionize healthcare. These AI-powered, self-serve pods provide advanced diagnostics, personalized health plans, and a range of Health Apps for various medical needs. Initially launching in major U.S. cities, these CarePods aim to make healthcare more accessible and personalized. Forward, backed by significant growth capital and led by a team of top doctors, is addressing major healthcare challenges such as cost, accessibility, and quality with this technology.

    Forward, a healthcare company, has announced the launch of its innovative product, the Forward CarePod, which represents a significant advancement in the intersection of technology and healthcare. This marks a major milestone as the world’s first AI doctor’s office. The Forward CarePods integrate artificial intelligence with medical expertise to offer a new paradigm in healthcare delivery.

    The Forward CarePods are self-serve, AI-powered units that provide an immersive experience, putting individuals in control of their health. These pods offer advanced diagnostics, personalized health plans, and a premium in-person experience. Upon entering a CarePod, users gain access to a wide range of Health Apps designed for various health concerns, including disease detection, biometric body scans, and blood testing. Forward is deploying these CarePods in malls, gyms, and offices, with plans to expand their footprint significantly in 2024. Initial launches are happening across major U.S. cities like San Francisco, New York, Chicago, and Philadelphia​​.

    The Health Apps utilized in the CarePods are built on Forward’s proprietary AI technology, which leverages clinical expertise and the latest medical research to create diagnostic tools and robust care plans. These apps address a range of disease areas, such as diabetes, hypertension, depression, and anxiety. Forward plans to expand the Health Apps to cover more areas like prenatal care, advanced cancer screening, and polygenic risk analysis. The data from CarePod visits are securely integrated into Forward’s platform, enabling continuous health monitoring and in-depth evaluations. Members can access their health data anytime through the Forward mobile app, with memberships starting at $99 per month​​.

    The development of the Forward CarePod and its Health Apps is led by a team of world-class doctors from renowned institutions like Harvard, Johns Hopkins, and Columbia. This ensures that deep medical knowledge and empathy are combined with advanced technology, providing top-notch care. As the deployment of CarePods increases, healthcare access will expand beyond geographical limitations. Forward’s medical team, not AI, makes all care decisions, thus ensuring a high standard of care and continuous updates of health data and personalized plans​​.

    Forward has also announced securing $100M in growth capital for the manufacturing and deployment of the CarePods. This funding comes from various sources, including blue-chip venture funds and notable AI and medical leaders. Forward, established in 2016, has been addressing the fundamental challenges in healthcare – cost, accessibility, and quality – and aims to use technology to scale care globally. The company already operates a vertically integrated, direct-to-consumer healthcare system with over 100 primary care clinicians across 19 locations nationwide​​.

    This announcement represents a significant leap in healthcare, offering a futuristic, tech-driven solution to long-standing healthcare challenges. The integration of AI and medical expertise in a consumer-friendly format like the CarePods has the potential to transform the landscape of health services, making advanced healthcare more accessible and personalized.

  • Understanding Generations: From Baby Boomers to Generation Alpha

    Generations are cohorts of people born in the same date range and who share similar cultural experiences. The concept of generations helps in understanding the social and cultural shifts over time. Let’s delve into each generation, their time frames, characteristics, and notable figures.

    Baby Boomers (1946-1964)

    Born post-World War II during a period of substantial increase in birth rates, Baby Boomers grew up during a time of great change, including the Civil Rights Movement and the Vietnam War. Notable figures include Bill Gates (1955), a pioneer in the personal computing revolution, and Madonna (1958), an influential figure in music.

    Generation X (1965-1980)

    Often called the “latchkey” generation, Gen Xers grew up during a time of declining population growth and are known for being independent, resourceful, and tech-savvy. Famous Gen Xers include Barack Obama (1961), the 44th President of the United States, and J.K. Rowling (1965), the author of the Harry Potter series.

    Millennials (1981-1996)

    Also known as Generation Y, Millennials are the first generation to come of age in the new millennium. They are characterized by their comfort with digital technology and social media. Notable Millennials include Mark Zuckerberg (1984), co-founder of Facebook, and Serena Williams (1981), a renowned tennis player.

    Generation Z (1997-2012)

    Gen Zers are true digital natives, having been exposed to the internet, social networks, and mobile systems from a young age. They are seen as more progressive and entrepreneurial. Examples include Malala Yousafzai (1997), an activist for female education, and Billie Eilish (2001), a Grammy-winning artist.

    Generation Alpha (2013-Present)

    The most recent generation, Alpha, is the first to be born entirely in the 21st century. These children are growing up in a hyper-connected world of technology. While it’s early to define their characteristics or list famous personalities, they are poised to be the most technologically immersed generation yet.

    Each generation has its unique set of values, attitudes, and experiences, influenced by the social, political, and economic events of their formative years. Understanding these generational differences is crucial in comprehending the evolution of societal norms and behaviors over time.