A response to this:
https://crookedtimber.org/2023/11/15/silicon-valleys-worldview-is-not-just-an-ideology-its-a-personality-disorder/

Surveillance and Manipulation

While concerns about surveillance and data manipulation are valid, it’s important to recognize the broader context. Many Silicon Valley companies have made significant efforts to improve data privacy and security. These measures are often driven by both consumer demand and regulatory requirements, illustrating a more complex picture than simply profit-driven surveillance.

Disruption and Monopoly

The focus on disruption has undoubtedly led to market dominance in some areas. However, this disruption has also often resulted in significant consumer benefits, like improved services, lower costs, and technological advancements that were previously unimaginable.

Oligarchy and Autocracy

Silicon Valley’s relationship with governments is more nuanced than the portrayal of a simple shift towards autocracy. Many tech leaders actively engage in philanthropy and social causes, leveraging their resources for global benefit, which contradicts the notion of a solely autocratic ambition.

Inequality and Concentration of Capital

While there is indeed a concentration of wealth in Silicon Valley, this wealth has also funded numerous startups and innovations that contribute to the economy. Additionally, many tech companies are actively working on diversity and inclusion initiatives to combat inequality.

Negation of Human Rights

It’s an oversimplification to claim that Silicon Valley negates human rights. Many tech companies are at the forefront of championing various social causes, including human rights. This commitment is often reflected in their corporate policies and social initiatives.

Racism, Misogyny, and Eugenics

Although issues of racism and misogyny exist in Silicon Valley, as they do in many industries, there is a growing awareness and active measures being taken to address these problems. The industry has seen a significant push towards greater diversity and inclusivity.

Destruction of Human Agency

The claim that Silicon Valley destroys human agency overlooks the numerous ways in which technology has empowered individuals, giving them tools for creativity, learning, and personal growth.

Media Control and State Exploitation

While there are instances of media manipulation and tax avoidance strategies, it’s not a universal practice in Silicon Valley. Many tech companies actively support journalistic endeavors and have a transparent approach to taxation and corporate responsibility.

Blame and Denial of Responsibility

The tech industry is increasingly acknowledging its role in societal issues and is taking steps to address them. This includes efforts in ethical AI, responsible data usage, and engaging in dialogues about technology’s impact on society.

Narrow Definition of Intelligence

Silicon Valley’s emphasis on engineering and mathematical skills doesn’t necessarily equate to a dismissal of other forms of intelligence. The tech industry has increasingly recognized the importance of diverse skill sets, including emotional intelligence, creativity, and interdisciplinary knowledge.

Long-termism and AI Risks

Focusing on long-term AI risks doesn’t inherently mean neglecting current societal issues. Many in Silicon Valley are actively engaged in addressing present challenges while also preparing for future technological impacts.

While Silicon Valley is not without its flaws, the portrayal of its ideology as a personality disorder overlooks the complexities and positive contributions of the tech industry. A more balanced view recognizes both the challenges and the significant advancements Silicon Valley has brought to the modern world.