,

Palmer Luckey on War 2.0: Nuclear Tests, Starlink and Jensen Huang

Palmer Luckey tells Andrew Ross Sorkin that America should resume nuclear testing, that Musk was right to limit Starlink in Ukraine, and that China wants Jensen Huang gone. The 51-minute conversation, filmed at The New York Times DealBook Summit and published November 19, 2026, also covers Project Meridian (the Pentagon’s 120-day study of future war, which Luckey co-leads with Elon Musk), the renaming of the Defense Department, AI weapons, public executions and why he has still not forgiven the people who pushed him out of Facebook.

TLDW

The Anduril founder argues that the US needs nuclear tests not to check its warheads but to learn whether modern electronics survive an electromagnetic pulse, and lays out how an adversary could exploit that gap without killing anyone. He defends Musk on Starlink by pointing out that the Pentagon will not risk its own Starshield network for Ukraine, says weapons AI is a different technology from chatbots, and wants Huang back at Nvidia even though he disagrees with Huang on chip exports. He also defends the Department of War name, his seat on Project Meridian, and televised executions as a check on state power.

Thoughts

Luckey’s case for nuclear testing is stronger than the headline makes it sound, because it is about electronics, not bombs. Cold War tests lined up pickup trucks, radios, ventilators and refinery equipment to see which survived the electromagnetic pulse, which could be restarted and which were fried for good, and much of today’s hardening still rests on that data. The models, he says, were built for transistors thousands of times larger than the ones in a phone, so nobody knows what a high-altitude burst does to modern gear, including the autonomous weapons his own company builds. His scenario is the useful part: a Chinese “test” in space whose pulse happens to disable US and South Korean equipment on the peninsula while North Korea’s older artillery keeps working. A weapon that disables an army without killing anyone is exactly the kind an adversary might think it could use without starting a nuclear war. The counterargument is that American tests would give Russia and China cover to test too, and they arguably have more to learn. But “I am not confident my stuff can survive” is an unusual admission from a weapons maker, and it is the argument his opponents need to answer.

His Jensen Huang argument is the most counterintuitive thing he says, and probably right on its own terms. Luckey opposes selling chips to China, so he should be glad to see the industry’s leading advocate of China sales gone. Instead he says “China wants Jensen out, so I want him in.” His reasoning is that Huang was on the side of Chinese AI companies, not the Chinese government: Beijing wants its own chip industry, which is why about 600,000 H200s have been stuck in Hong Kong awaiting import approval. Removing the American CEO those companies relied on serves that goal. It matches what Gavin Baker argued at TomorrowX the same week, from the other side of the export debate. The weak spot is that it reasons from motive (“China wants it, so it is bad”), and he offers no account of what the board should do about the reasons Huang left.

On Starlink, Luckey’s best point is the one he says he forgot to make first. The Pentagon has its own military network, Starshield, and he says it does not want Ukraine relying on it because Russia would then target it. If the US government will not put its own constellation at risk for Ukraine, he asks, why should Musk risk a civilian network that US forces also use? It is a fair steelman, and it leads to his bleakest line: the West does not want Ukraine to win, only “to not lose for as long as possible.” The facts are messier than he allows. In October, Ukrainian drones were hit by speed limits on Starshield itself, and Musk said the US government controls that network, so the line between Musk’s choices and Washington’s is not as clean as either side claims.

One principle runs through his most provocative positions: make state power visible so voters can judge it. He wants executions public and violent rather than “medicalized and hidden away,” because public executions of people the public did not think deserved it are what ended the death penalty in many states. He would allow more real-time war footage for the same reason, and he defends the Department of War name as more honest about what the money buys. But earlier in the same interview he praises Nixon’s madman theory and says leaders “took liberties” with the truth for good strategic reasons, so his transparency stops where deterrence starts. That is a coherent view, but it means the public sees the costs only when officials decide it should.

His defense of AI weapons rests on separating them from chatbots, and it mostly holds. A seeker classifying a destroyer from radar, thermal and electromagnetic signatures is not a language model that can say “you’re right, that wasn’t a warship,” and he argues it is more discriminating than the older seekers that went for “the hottest thing in this area.” He concedes that others have used language models for targeting and made mistakes, and asks whether the result was still a net good. That is the self-driving car standard, and the honest version of it requires the casualty data that militaries rarely publish, which brings him back to his own transparency argument.

Key Takeaways

  • Luckey says the week’s outages reflect AI tools making exploits easier, often for money, and that defense will win in the long run; on November 17 the White House and the Director of National Intelligence said there was no evidence of a cyberattack.
  • His preparedness advice is three days of water and dry food, and refilling prescriptions 72 hours before they run out, because the US recovers well within three days but not within 12 or 24 hours.
  • He takes more credit than anyone else for the Department of War name, which he says he pushed with Howard Lutnick during the transition, citing deterrence, honesty about spending, focus, morale and repelling the wrong recruits.
  • He says Xi Jinping’s purge of his top generals means China is not ready to act, and that the US was lucky it happened before the war with Iran.
  • He says weapons makers should be “a dog on a chain”: who America sells to is for the republic to decide, not executives.
  • He argues no AI model can be controlled at the level of use, since every major model has been jailbroken within months, and he fears bad people with good AI more than superintelligence.
  • Project Meridian is meant to look at warfare decades out, unconstrained by what is possible today; the group decided to focus on ideas without existing champions in the Pentagon, such as weather control.
  • Responding to criticism from a former Pentagon civilian-harm official, he says industry advisory boards date back to World War II, that Meridian has more than 20 members including retired generals and admirals, and that its report will be public.
  • He wants nuclear testing resumed mainly to measure how modern electronics, from phones to autonomous weapons, survive an electromagnetic pulse.
  • He says he has been working for about ten years on floating offshore platforms for industry nobody wants nearby, such as ore processing, refining and desalination, and that data centers are a small part of it.
  • He expects most AI to run locally on more powerful chips and is skeptical of the giant data center as the main way AI spreads.
  • He opposes chip exports to China but wants Huang back at Nvidia, arguing that Huang was on the side of Chinese AI companies, not the Chinese government.
  • He blames the Oculus colleagues he made rich, not Mark Zuckerberg, for his 2017 firing, and says Anduril’s work with Meta on soldier headsets is worth doing because it can keep troops alive.

Chapters

0:00 Erebor, Missile Bases and the Outages

Sorkin introduces Luckey as 33, the founder of Oculus and Anduril and a backer of Erebor, the bank named for the Lonely Mountain; Luckey corrects the Tolkien reference to the dwarves’ post-dragon kingdom. Asked about the week’s outages, he says attackers are outpacing old systems and “it’s time to start running.” He jokes that his underground missile base, home to the world’s largest video game collection, is a poor bunker because a reciprocating saw can cut the door hinges in about ten minutes.

5:00 Why the Department of War

Reading from notes he prepared for Howard Lutnick, Luckey lists his reasons for the name: “If you want peace, you prepare for war,” a war budget is easier to weigh against hospitals and schools than a defense budget, and the department should drop work unrelated to fighting. He adds that the Department of War won its wars and the Department of Defense did not, and that the name repels people who would not serve under it.

9:00 Iran, China, Stockpiles and Ukraine

Luckey agrees that winning decisively is the best deterrent to China, and says Beijing saw its equipment fail in Venezuela. He defends the president’s claim that stockpiles are fine as the right thing for a president to say, citing Nixon’s madman theory. He says he supported Ukraine before most Republicans, recalls meeting Volodymyr Zelensky in New York, and argues Trump inherited a Europe that ignored his warnings about Russian energy.

17:00 Elon Musk, Starlink and Starshield

Luckey gives what he calls a steelman for Musk: Russia could lawfully target a constellation knowingly used for offensive strikes, and destroying it would also cut US capabilities that depend on the same satellites. He says the government should not leave that choice to a CEO without promising to defend the network, and notes that it will not give Ukraine its own military Starshield network for the same reason.

22:00 Can AI Be Controlled, and AI Weapons

Raising the Pentagon’s designation of Anthropic as a supply chain risk, Sorkin asks whether any model is controllable. Luckey says no, since every major model has been jailbroken, but AI has no physical arms yet and data centers can be switched off. He calls himself an “AI OG,” noting Anduril Industries abbreviates to AI, and says weapons autonomy is a different and more reliable technology than chatbots.

27:00 Project Meridian and Its Critics

Luckey says Meridian, run through MITRE, recruited people partly for a science-fiction view of war decades out, and that he had just come from a meeting at Cheyenne Mountain. Sorkin reads a critique from Wes Bryant, a retired Air Force master sergeant who led Pentagon civilian-harm assessments, calling it oligarchy. Luckey answers that Eric Schmidt never faced that question for serving on the Defense Innovation Board, and asks people to judge the public report.

33:00 Why He Wants Nuclear Testing Back

He gives two reasons. The weaker one, which he admits is undeveloped, is that mutually assured destruction depends on people fearing nuclear weapons. The stronger one is that nobody has tested what an electromagnetic pulse does to modern electronics, leaving a tempting option for an enemy who wants to disable US forces without killing them.

37:00 Public Executions and Televised War

Luckey defends a televised execution as a libertarian position: capital punishment should be rare, carried out openly by those holding a monopoly on violence, and visible enough that the public can react. Asked whether war should be broadcast too, he says he has not thought deeply about it, but cites Vietnam and the Gulf War as cases where visibility shaped public judgment.

41:00 Floating Platforms and Jensen Huang

He describes offshore platforms for industry that communities reject, says reports about floating AI data centers miss that he has worked on this for a decade, and predicts most AI will run locally. On Nvidia he says interim CEO Colette Kress “is not Jensen,” and that Huang’s personal relationships are why partners do business with Nvidia, since “paper means nothing.”

46:00 Facebook, Grudges and Teaming With Zuckerberg

Luckey says people should be judged on their actions in context, not by how things turned out, so being better off now does not excuse being fired over a 2016 donation to a pro-Trump group despite strong reviews. He blames the Oculus colleagues he made rich, not Zuckerberg, who he says acted on his deputies’ advice. That is why he could partner with Meta on Anduril’s Army headset program.

Notable Quotes

“If you want peace, you prepare for war. Nobody says if you want peace, prepare for defense.”

Palmer Luckey, on renaming the Defense Department

“I’m a dog on a chain and I need to be kept that way.”

Palmer Luckey, on who should decide where weapons are sold

“They just want them to not lose for as long as possible, which is a bizarre and absurd warfighting position.”

Palmer Luckey, on the West and Ukraine

“I am way more afraid of the civilian collateral side for dumb weapons than I am for smart weapons.”

Palmer Luckey, on autonomous weapons

“I am not confident my stuff can survive even when I follow the rules and the rad hardening guidelines.”

Palmer Luckey, on why he wants nuclear testing resumed

“China wants Jensen out, so I want him in.”

Palmer Luckey, on Nvidia’s leadership

“It’s probably better for everybody that I got fired. But I have not let it go.”

Palmer Luckey, on leaving Facebook

Watch the full conversation here.

Related Reading